Find The Best Bathroom Scale for You
Modern bathroom scales are a far cry from yesterday’s models. Mechanical scales, once the only kind you could buy, are still available and are still favored by some.
However, these scales also have some downsides. They display weight with an analog dial and needle pointer, which introduces some imprecision compared to digital displays (see below). In addition, the inner workings of a mechanical scale can be surprisingly delicate, made up of small pieces, including springs that lend themselves to wear and tear, introducing inaccuracies.
Photo above – Trim Digital Bathroom Scale
See my full reviews below, including
- best overall bathroom scale
- best body-fat bathroom scale
- best smart bathroom scale
- best cheap smart bathroom scale
While mechanical scales are purely mechanical in nature, digital scales use load cells to convert the physical weight on the scale to an electrical signal that’s displayed on a readout with a precision that’s as close as a tenth of a pound.
In addition to greater accuracy, the advantage of having weight represented by an electrical signal is that it allows for a lot of added functionality. Some of that is fun stuff — like the ability for the scale to speak your weight aloud, though those that are overly self-conscious about their weight might not find that a particularly helpful attribute.
Other features are more useful, however. Some digital scales will also display your Body Mass Index (BMI), a measure of fitness that’s based on your weight and height. Some are body fat scales, sending small electrical pulses through a user’s body in an attempt to gauge body weight/density.
Smart scales are digital scales that take things a step further. They wirelessly connect to a smartphone, tablet or directly to the Internet via Wi-Fi and/or Bluetooth, and integrate with compatible apps and web sites to help you keep tabs on your overall fitness. Data transmitted includes weight, of course, but often other measures such as body fat, BMI, and more, such as heart rate. Many smart scales include built-in memory to store multiple user profiles and allow a single scale to serve the needs of an entire family. Some can display information collected from the web, such as the predicted weather.
Finding the best bathroom scales
While mechanical scales are still very much available, digital scales tend to score more favorably in user and, especially, expert reviews, and are the best choice these days for most buyers.
To find the best basic, body fat and smart digital scales, I turned first to a bevy of experts, including ConsumerReports.org, TheSweethome.com, Good Housekeeping and others, putting the most weight (pun intended) on those sources that perform hands on testing.
I also looked at the extensive user reviews available at sites such as Amazon.com, BestBuy.com, Walmart.com and elsewhere. These user reviews help us fill in the gaps regarding factors such as real-world ease-of-use and long term reliability. The results are my selections as the Best Reviewed bathroom scales for any user and any budget.
Best Overall Bathroom Scale
The EatSmart Precision Digital Bathroom Scale lacks much in the way of bells and whistles, but offers everything you need in a modern bathroom scale. It’s easy to use, easy to read, economical, and reasonably accurate.
Its 400 pound weight capacity makes it suitable for most individuals, and its clear glass platform fits in with most bathroom décor. A tape measure so that you can also keep track of inches, hopefully, lost is also included.
- Large, 3.5-inch backlit display
- 400-pound weight capacity
- 0.2-pound measurement increments
- Company has well regarded customer service
- Some small quibbles about accuracy
The EatSmart Precision Digital Bathroom Scale is a solid performer with good accuracy and reliability in a sleek, attractive package. It’s easy to use, with no tap-on required to calibrate the scale before use and a large, backlit display for readability. The company has also established a track record for proactively reaching out to users that report less than perfect satisfaction to make sure any issues are fully addressed.
Breaking it down
Excellent performance. While the experts at Good Housekeeping say that the EatSmart Precision isn’t the most accurate it has tested, most owners don’t share similar quibbles. User reviews regarding accuracy largely say they are pleased. Among those that aren’t, EatSmart offers responsive customer service, contacting each reviewer leaving negative feedback at Amazon.com to address concerns; in some cases even sending along a free replacement when one wasn’t requested. The majority of those users come back to report that their new scales are highly accurate performers.
Ease of use
No tap-on calibration necessary. The EatSmart Precision Digital Bathroom Scale couldn’t be simpler to use. One issue with earlier versions was that they required a toe tap to turn on and calibrate the scale, but that’s been eliminated in a 2014 update. The scale’s large 3.5-inch backlit display offers easy readability, even in dim lighting conditions.
Strong track record. The EatSmart scale has been available for quite a few years, and feedback indicates that while some initial quality issues are not unheard of, those are usually quickly addressed by the company. We also saw lots of user reviews at Amazon.com that reflected long-term use, often after several years, and most owners say that their scales are still going strong. The Precision digital scale is backed by EatSmart’s two-year guarantee.
Sleek, slim design attractive in any setting. Users praise the EatSmart Precision’s slim, sleek appearance, which they say fits in well with nearly any décor. The 12- by 13-inch platform isn’t the best for large users, but helps keep the footprint small, a plus in a tight bathroom.
Best Body-Fat Scale